Abstract
Citation based metrics are widely used to assess the impact of research published in journals. This paper presents the results of a research study to verify the accuracy of data and calculations of journal impact metrics presented in Web of Science (WoS) and Scopus in the case of three journals of information and library science. Data collected from the websites of journals were compared with that of two citation extended databases. The study manually calculated Journal Impact Factor (JIF) and Impact per Publication (IPP) in accordance with formulas given in the databases. Data were also collected from the Google Scholar for the purpose of comparison. The study found discrepancies in two sets of data and bibliometric values, i.e., systematic values presented in WoS and Scopus and calculated in this study. Commercial databases presented inflated measures based on fabricated or erroneous data. The study is of practical importance to researchers, universities and research financing bodies that consider these bibliometric indicators as a good tool for measuring performance, assessing, and evaluating research quality as well as researchers. Normal 0 false false false SV X-NONE X-NONE
Syed Rahmatullah Shah, Khalid Mahmood. (2016) Validation of journal impact metrics of Web of Science and Scopus, Pakistan Journal of Information Management and Libraries, Vol 18, Issue 2.
-
Views
579 -
Downloads
84
Article Details
Volume
Issue
Type
Language
