An Analitical Study of Opinions of Shaikh Albani about Invalidity of Hadiths of Sonan-e-Tirimiz
تلخیص
Shaikh Nasir ud Din Albani is great mohaddith of last century. He wrote more than 300 books. He established few principles for acceptance or rejection of hadith. Shaikh Nasir ud Din Albani considered 8 hadiths of “Sonan e Tirmizi” as “Sahih” in his book “Sahih w Daeef Sonane-e-Tirmizi” while “daeef” in his other books.
According to Shaikh Albani a daeef hadith is acceptable (Sahih or Hasan) if found with another transmission (Motabe or Shahid) in Sahih Bukhari or any other book of Hadith. We found other transmission of these 8 hadiths as “Motabe” or “Shahid” in Sahih Bukhari. Imam Tirmizi also considered these 8 hadiths as “sahih” or “hasan” in his Sonan e Tirmizi. After that it is concluded that these 8 hadiths should be considered as “Sahih” or “Hasan“.
With this method we can review the books of Shaikh Albani and solve the contradiction of his opinions and we can also solve the contradiction of his opinion with other Mohadithin to find authentic status of Hadith.
Dr. Muhammad Shahid. (2018) سنن الترمذی کی روایات کی تضعیف میں شیخ البانی ؒ کی آراء کا تجزیاتی مطالعہ, , Volume 17, Issue 2.
-
Views
591 -
Downloads
43